Different Graft Choices For The Anterior Cruciate Ligament 

Anna Baysinger 

University of Alaska Fairbanks 

BIO 111: Human Anatomy and Physiology I

Professor Don Larson 

November 20, 2025

The knee is composed of many different structures to help humans do various activities such as walk, run, play sports, squat, etc. My objective covered in my STEAM project is to know the structure of the knee joint. The knee joint is the largest and most complex joint of the human body. It has three joints in the single cavity that help flexion and extension of the knee, as well as many muscles that help support the movements. There are four major ligaments that help with stability. Posterior cruciate ligament (PCL), medial collateral ligament (MCL), lateral collateral ligament (LCL), anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) that all work together to support the movements of the knee. Unfortunately, one of the most common ligament tears in the knee is an ACL tear. ACL tears are the most common tear that can happen to a person in sports, especially a female athlete. 

Female athletes are 2 to 8 times more likely to tear the anterior cruciate ligament than men are, something researchers are still trying to figure out (Giugliano, 2007). Most non-contact ACL injuries are due to cutting or planting in an unnatural way which is about 29% of reported injuries (Giugliano, 2007). Second, is straight knee landing which is about 28% of injuries (Giugliano, 2007). Third, one step landing when the knee is hyperextended, this is 26% of reported injuries (Giugliano, 2007). All these movements are what the ACL controls, it keeps the knee stable to cut and change of directions. ACL tears happen because of too much stretch or force that causes it to snap. Most of the time, to fix the tear, people undergo surgery. With surgery there are four choices surgeons give you. Hamstring graft, Quadricep graft, patella tendon graft, and allograft. Depending on the person and activity level depends on what graft will best suit the patient.  

Now each graft has its positives and negatives but which one is the best, and is easier to recover to get back to normal life?

Let’s start out with the Allograft. Usually surgeons use the allograft on older people, who don’t plan on going back into sports and aren’t as active. There are many positives that an allograft provides, like less surgical time because of not harvesting the graft from another site of the patient’s body as well as faster recovery. The downsides to this graft is the body possibly rejecting the graph and many infections. This graft is not great for a young athlete wanting to get back into sports but is proven to have the same success rates as an autograft with people who are over the age of forty (Buerba, 2021). 

The Hamstring graft is another great option, but many surgeons prefer to avoid it because of the complex negatives the graft imposes. Some of the disadvantages to this graft are longer healing time, graft failure, and knee flexion weakness (Buerba, 2021). Another big disadvantage to this graft is getting hamstring strength back after taking the graft out of the hamstring. Most of the time it takes longer for these patients to recover especially if the hamstring is important for the patient’s everyday life. The Hamstring graft overall has one of the highest failure rates and rerupture rates (Buerba, 2021). 

The Quadricep graft is one that is growing in popularity. Because of the increase in success rate. It is one the strongest and thickest grafts out of the four (Buerba, 2021). Some disadvantages to using the graft is prolonged weakness in the quad after surgery. Before patients can get back to running and jumping they have to grow the quad muscle which takes about four to five months depending on the person. This graft has a lot of positives, less of a surgical site, and it’s preferred for athletes. 

The Patellar tendon graft is also one of the best and has been popular for many years for ACL reconstruction. However, studies have come out that there are many disadvantages to this graft. There can be patellar fractures, patellar tendonitis, and anterior knee pain that can happen after surgery (Cerulli, 2013). People who often get this graft often suffer from pain from the patellar or tibia donor site, there is often pain when kneeling or pressure on the site. The positives that the patellar tendon has is fast recovery time, young people often recover and return back to their sports, and it’s also a strong graft (Buerba, 2021). 

Overall, each graft has its specific negatives and positives. For older people, grafts such as the allograft would be in their best interest. As an older person your ligaments aren’t in great shape as a younger person, so taking one from a donor would help have almost the same strength as their old ACL, as well as less surgical sites. For younger people, a quadricep graft or a patellar tendon graft, they both have high rates of younger people returning back to their sport, as well as great success rates and recovery time. The hamstring graft is becoming less popular for a contender for a graft. It has the highest rates of failure and often over time fails and loosens. (Buerba, 2021). All grafts usually take an immense amount of physical therapy to get back what the knee once was. ACL surgery is scary, however, people usually come back stronger than before. 

Works Cited

Buerba, R. A., Boden, S. A., & Lesniak, B. (2021). Graft Selection in Contemporary 

Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction. JAAOS: Global Research and Reviews, 5(10). https://doi.org/10.5435/jaaosglobal-d-21-00230

Cerulli, G., Giacomo Placella, Sebastiani, E., Tei, M. M., Speziali, A., & Manfreda, F. 

(2013). ACL Reconstruction: Choosing the Graft. Joints, 1(1), 18. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4295687/#b41-18-24

Giugliano, D. N., & Solomon, J. L. (2007). ACL Tears in Female Athletes. Physical 

Medicine and Rehabilitation Clinics of North America, 18(3), 417–438. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pmr.2007.05.002

‌

‌

‌

One Comment

  1. This project breaks down the structure of the knee. Anna discussed the four major ligaments: posterior cruciate ligament (PCL), medial collateral ligament (MCL), lateral collateral ligament (LCL), and anterior cruciate ligament (ACL). Focus placed on ACL injuries in female athletes as they incur the highest rate of injury according to her study of (Giugliano, 2007). This project outlined the strategies in which the ACL is repaired through surgery. There are 4 different ways that an ACL can be repaired; hamstring graft, quadricep graft, patella tendon graft, and an allograft. The hamstring graft and allograft are the least preferred methods as they can lead to reinjury or inability to continue sports if injured at a young age. The quadricep graft is the preferred method by most athletes as it has less recovery time and higher rate of recovery with a larger graft site. The patella tendon graft also has high success rate but has been known to have reoccurring pain even after fully recovering. Anna’s study of surgical intervention strategies for the ACL allows for greater depth of knowledge in the knee structure as a whole. I was unable to view the artwork for this piece.
    Giugliano, D. N., & Solomon, J. L. (2007). ACL Tears in Female Athletes. Physical
    Medicine and Rehabilitation Clinics of North America, 18(3), 417–438. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pmr.2007.05.002 (edited)

    Candace Jackson

Comments are closed.